Great Britain makes peace with Hitler in 1940

I completely agree, ok then BE I am just going to say I agree to disagree with you on this one and the other thread as well.

 

In this scenario the full Japanese fleet was deployed at Midway thus the victory which left Hawaii wide open.
This is before we mention the German and Italian U-Boat threat to American shipping.

 

Britain doesn’t need convoys, as it isn’t at war.
Japan and Italy both wont challenge Britain white she is not engaged elsewhere.
Mussolini had 18 years to take on Britain before he eventually did and that was only after we where fighting the Germans same with the Japanese.

 

These theories have both been explored before be Britain’s top historian AJP Taylor who agrees Britain gained nothing but last a lot from the war and John Charmley and Alan Clarke said much the same.
John Charmley has all so written several very interesting counter factuals on British neutrality that go up to about 1942.
Im trying to take it a bit further here based on what each country and its leaders are likely to do next.

 

Give me somthing specific you disagree on.

 

I am not going to rewrite everthing that I have writen in this thread just because you are to bothered to read it yourself, but very basically, I disagree with everthing you are saying, that is everthing you have changed I it just not possible If you want to understand read the whole thread again please.

 

So it's not possible that Lord Halifax could accept the role as PM?

 

Not as realistic as you may like to think, as eveyone is disagreeing with you.

 

Myself, Lord Halifax and Britains top historians must all be wrong then cos a few people in an internet forum said so.

 

Man... you really are way too up yourself.

 

Ya THINK?? lol. And I thought some of the other "What Ifs" were not close to being in the realm of being realistic.

 

Perhaps you would be kind enough to provide some sources or names of these "Britains top historians", as to better educate little old us on the matter?

 

C'mon guys. This is getting old. We're getting new folks here and we don't need to look like bickering old sods. I think it is time to close out this thread.

 

J P Taylor, Alan Clarke, John Charmley, Frank Ellis etc

 

Oh that gives me a good idea,

"What if Germany invade Antarctica?"


Sorry, me being a fool

Please close the thread, its at its climax of anger and oddities.