Group Build #1 Member's Vote - come and vote now!

Dear all,

I hereby present to you: The Group Build #1 Member's Vote!
I kindly ask anyone who sees this thread to vote on one of these builds. The purpose is to decide on a winner!

The models are sorted by date of completion, the one that was finished first is added first to the list of models.
A brief presentation of the models follows:

SturmTiger's JADGTIGER (1:72)


JCalhoun's STURMGESCHUTZ 3 (1:48)


-DMPN - Founderer's JAGDPANTHER (1:48)


1950willys' HETZER (1:48?)
(Click to enlarge!)

Boba Nette's JAGDPANTHER (1:72)


Thanks a lot, from all of us!
Greets,
PanzerProfile

 

OK, I voted for the Stug by J Calhoun. My reasons are:-

1. The base colour is well done (more accurate) with good subtle weathering (suitable for a fairly new vehicle).

2. The overall build quality is again good (best of the bunch so far as I can see)

 

I voted for the Sturmgeschütz as well. The Jagdpanzer 38 photograph isn't good enough for me to properly evaluate it, but either that or the Jagdtiger would probably be my second pick.

 

It's pretty close actually - I think that the Stug is just about the most convincing - it's also a more interesting subject - more lumpy and dynamic - but I tried not to let that influence me. Actually I would happily give any of them shelf space.

Thanks for sharing, chaps.

 

The pleasure was ours Lone Wolf.And thank you for participating.

 

I was hesitant to vote, since I've had models in shows, and the feeling at voting time sucks.

However, I also voted for JC, based solely on my first impression of each model as I viewed it. Color, tone, weathering, all look good, but JC's looked the most realistic to me as I viewed them.

PLEASE, please, please, none of you feel discouraged by my comments. None of them looked bad. They all showed good effort, and attention.

It seems to take forever to get the knack, but when it comes, you'll feel really good about it. Honest!

 

I voted for JCalhoun's StuG. In my opinion, it gives the best overall impression of all. I like particularly the colours as well as the work on the side. Also, 1950willys' Hetzer seems very nice too--it would be my second choice.
Overall, all of you have done a very good job!

 

Fantastic workmanship....well done to everyone.

I voted for JCalhoun......because I liked the look of his model (sorry, girly reason)

 

Just bumping it to the top.

 

Reminds me of a Stug I seen at the Canadian war Museum except this one dosent have a dozen holes going through it.

 

Thanks to all who have voted already!

I forgot to mention that more pics of these models are shown here.

 

Hey PP,can you make this topic sticky?

 

Done...

Wow, this sure is a landslide victory for Jody. Congratulations!

Well done to all, though, this work is outstanding without exception.

 

Way to go Jody, well deserved for sure, Personally I had a lot of fun with this, cant wait till the next one..thanks everyone

 

Thanks all!

 

Dear all,

Due to unforeseen computerproblems (my computer crashed two days ago) I will not be able to complete judgement on the models for a while.
I send you all my deepest apologies and promise I will get back to you as soon as I'm able to.
thanks,

PP

 

December 7th has come and gone.A big congratulations to JC for his StuG.I knew that was going to be the one to beat.Well done!

 

Thanks!

 

Dear All, and ofcourse mostly JCalhoun,

It had a long time coming because of my computerproblems, but the team's decision on the winner is finally done. The ranking on which we decided is as follows:

1. JCalhoun
2. SturmTiger (shared second place)
(3)1950's Willys (shared second place)
4. Boba Nette
5. -DMPN- Founderer

So first of all I'd really like to congratulate JCalhoun with his victory!
Ofcourse the forum Team decided that you deserve something of a winner's prize. We therefore designed a certificate that we'd like to send you. If you just PM me your emailadress, I'll send it to you as soon as I can.
Secondly, You may decide which tank family is going to be the subject of Group Build no. 2!
I really hope that we can make GB2 as succesful as part one.
Many thanks to SturmTiger for bringing this item to our attention and all the ideas and efforts he made to accomplish such a nice competition.
Greets,
PP

 

Thanks PP.I hope everyone had as good a time as I did.This competition kind of pushed me to do the best job possible.Although the finished vehicle is similar in workmanship to the many others I have built,I do believe it looks a tad bit better.I hope the next Group Build is just as successful.