Welcome to the WWII Forums! Log in or Sign up to interact with the community.

Hitlers biggest War Mistakes

Discussion in 'Leaders of World War 2' started by AL AMIN, Oct 26, 2005.

  1. KodiakBeer

    KodiakBeer Member

    Nov 20, 2012
    Likes Received:
    The Arid Zone
    All of this input on the German economy comes round to the same thing; a centralized economy doesn't work. In Germany's case, it was a centralized economy on steroids because of the pace of the war. The economy of the USSR creaked along for seventy years only because it had much greater raw material sources to exploit, but even so it ran badly and eventually stagnated into collapse competing against western capitalist economies.
    In Germany's case, they were able to run at a high pace only by looting the nations they occupied in the first surge of expansion, as well as their own dwindling stocks of materiel. One must view this in the light of post-war West Germany where (without the crippling debt of pre-war Germany) they were able to produce goods based on market demand and are prosperous until the present day.
    During the war, the centralized economy produced war materiel to one customer - itself. This is not sustainable. How could it be? They were producing a product that destroys itself, using their own labor as cannon fodder, and paying for it with treasure from occupied nations that was not renewable due to their own pillage and theft of those economies.
    National Socialism didn't work any better than any other type of socialism. And just to avoid the inevitable nit-picking, I define socialism as a government that actually directs production. I'm not talking about a capitalist social-welfare state where production is based on consumer demands.

  2. green slime

    green slime Member

    Nov 18, 2010
    Likes Received:
    Following the bombing of Pearl Harbor in 1941 and with the onset of World War II, the federal government set out to impose new or expanded controls over the country`s economy. On January 6, 1942, President Franklin D. Roosevelt announced some ambitious production goals to support the war. As a result, all of the country’s economic sectors were then under increased government control. While economists usually oppose price controls, it was a state of emergency.

    The government then sought the cooperation of those who controlled the resources needed to conduct the war successfully. It took many agencies to resolve disputes between workers and management, set price controls, and impose rationing on scarce commodities as part of the war effort. Such agencies as the War Production Board (WPB) and the Office of Price Administration (OPA) were created in 1942 to increase total production and to control wages and prices.

    Wage and price control measures, as well as regulating the hiring and firing of workers, was also initiated by the government. The National War Labor Board was established by an executive order of President Roosevelt on January 12, 1942. The board was responsible for determining the correct procedures for settling disputes that could possibly affect any war production. It was also authorized to approve wage increases and quickly adopted the Little Steel formula for wartime changes based on the rising cost of living.

    The Emergency Stabilization Act was passed in October 1942, which placed wages and agricultural prices under control. There were immediate wage restrictions, and in order to attract labor, the employers offered a range of such fringe benefits as pensions, medical insurance, paid holidays, and vacations. Because the foregoing were not paid out in cash, they did not violate the wage ceiling. Controlling output proved easier than controlling wages.

    The Office of War Mobilization then emerged in 1943 to reallocate the production of military matériel. In order to convert to military production, resources for the production of consumer goods had to be diverted. The great surge in munitions production reached its peak in 1943, after such motives as patriotism and financial incentives drew the necessary resources to war production centers.

    In June 1943, the OPA established more than 200 Industry Advisory Committees whose sole purpose was to aid the price control effort. The manufacture of such consumer items as refrigerators, automobiles and even housing materials was forbidden at that time. During World War II, many inflationary pressures were created by shortages of both goods and labor. The Consumer Price Index (CPI) increased by more than 35 percent. Strict limits were set on the manufacture of numerous consumer goods.

    The public supported price controls, and businesses supported them even before they were implemented. Most labor leaders cooperated with President Roosevelt by pledging not to strike. With their cooperation came an increase in union membership, which resulted in a general decrease in labor militancy.

    Despite the efforts of the National War Labor Board, the shortage of labor during World War II precipitated a sharp increase in wages. Congress passed the War Labor Disputes (Smith-Connally) Act on June 25, 1943, which authorized the president to take over plants needed for the war effort, thereby preventing further war production disruption because of labor disputes. Although strikes were prohibited, they still occurred.

    Social Security also was affected by the price controls. During the wartime crisis, Congress refused to raise the benefit levels (with the exception of veterans); however, it did increase the number of beneficiaries and contributors (taxpayers). With the war there was a revolution within government finances: Revenue demands led directly to a large increase in income tax rates and withholding on individuals.

    During the war, a positive measure began for some when the federal government stimulated and controlled the course of private industry by offering low-interest loans, generous tax credits and guaranteed purchase contracts for business ventures. In some cases the government went to great lengths to construct factories, then hand them over to private interests to operate.

    Rent control was another factor. In order to have an effect, the rent level must be below that which would otherwise prevail, because controls prevent rents that attain market clearing levels and shortages result. Many economists agree that rent controls are destructive.

    With war came the rationing of food and more price controls. For example, in 1945 the food situation had improved slightly and the statutory price of rice was reduced. In 1946, however, harvest difficulties and inflationary conditions created a widespread demand for an increase in prices. When there was no longer a shortage of food grains, there was no further need for price controls.
    belasar likes this.
  3. James Stewart

    James Stewart Active Member

    Jan 21, 2020
    Likes Received:
    Military 22/6/41.
    From the point of view of running a country which would, in turn, have an impact on a war effort when war came, so many.
    Often the agenda of the party was seen to be the priority.
  4. Kai-Petri

    Kai-Petri Kenraali

    Jul 31, 2002
    Likes Received:
    Declaring war to the USA in december 1941. Otherwise Fdr would not have a reason to start war for 2-3 years. Hitler did him a favour.
  5. Class of '42

    Class of '42 Active Member

    Mar 18, 2020
    Likes Received:
    Invasion of the Soviet Union and declaring war on the United States six months later... two biggest blunders...the rest like letting the British escape from Dunkirk, delaying Operation Barbarossa, micro-managing his armies and end up fighting on too many fronts, was secondary...1941 was really his downfall.
  6. Riter

    Riter Member

    Feb 12, 2020
    Likes Received:
    Don't invade Russia.

Share This Page