Welcome to the WWII Forums! Log in or Sign up to interact with the community.

The Germans do not invaded Crete in 1941

Discussion in 'Alternate History' started by lordroel, Oct 8, 2018.

Tags:
  1. lordroel

    lordroel Member

    Joined:
    Nov 2, 2017
    Messages:
    40
    Likes Received:
    1
    What if: Germans do not invaded Crete in 1941

    In 1941, Nazi Germany launched a successful invasion of the Greek island of Crete. But what if this had been unsuccessful? In this article, Nick Tingley examines how it could have seriously impacted the German invasion of Russia – and may have even changed the course of World War Two itself.

    In the early hours of a June morning in 1942, Maleme airfield was a hive of activity. For the first time since the failed German attempt to capture Crete in 1941, American bombers rolled up to the airstrip and their crews began their final preparations for a great attack, codenamed “Operation Tidal Wave”. Finally, a flare was launched into the sky and the rows of bombers began to race along the strip before leaping up into the sky. Once in the air, they were joined by escort craft from the nearby airfields of Heraklion and Rethymnon, and soon the bomber force began to turn north and disappeared away from the island. Their targets were the nine Ploiesti oil refineries in Romania that, under continuous air attack from the island fortress, soon became unusable for the Axis powers.

    As the bombers disappeared into the distance, the commander of the Allied ground troops on Crete, Major-General Bernard Freyberg VC, watched with satisfaction. As he watched, his mind returned to the two weeks in May 1941, when the determined soldiers of “Creforce” successful beat back a large German airborne invasion and showed the world that the Allies would not be defeated by Nazi Germany.

    Operation Mercury

    Unfortunately for Freyberg this was not the case. A year earlier, on the morning of May 20, 1941, the Germans launched an airborne invasion of Crete, codenamed Operation Mercury. Whilst the Germans had suffered heavy casualties, enough to convince Adolf Hitler that the German military should never again conduct a large-scale airborne operation, the 40,000 men of the Allied defense were soon overwhelmed and Crete became the latest possession of the Third Reich.

    The capture of Crete was perfect for the German military machine. Not only did it mean that the Balkan flank was secured only a few days before the invasion of Russia, Operation Barbarossa, was launched, but it also allowed the Germans to create a staging point to allow for easy troop movement between Europe and North Africa. From the airfields, the Germans were able to launch significant convoy strikes on ships travelling between Egypt and the Allies’ other island possessions in the Mediterranean: Malta and Cyprus.

    For the Allies, it represented a significant blow to their morale. The Battle of Crete had depended largely on the Allies holding the island’s airfields but disorganization and an unclear defensive plan had led to the airfields being captured and the Allied troops being overrun and forced to evacuate to Egypt. But the capture of Crete was more than just a military embarrassment; there was also a considerable fear that the Germans might use Crete as a staging point for an invasion of Cyprus or Egypt to support the German and Italian forces that were operating out of Libya further to the west. It was only when the Germans launched Operation Barbarossa that it became clear that this was not the intention.

    In Crete itself, the invasion and occupation led to a civil uprising amongst the civilians who lived there. For the first time in the war, the German Army encountered widespread resistance from the civilian population, with thousands of civilians taking up arms against their German invaders. During the first few months of the occupation, the Germans routinely executed male civilians in reprisal for the deaths of German soldiers. In the Massacres of Kondomari and Viannos alone, the death toll exceeded 500.

    The Barbarossa Question

    The Battle of Crete is one of the more interesting what ifs to have come out of the Second World War. For decades, historians have placed differing amounts of weight on the importance of the battle. For some, the capture of Crete was incidental and, had the battle gone the other way, would have made very little difference to the outcome of the war. Others have suggested that Crete was vitally important and point to its strategic location as the main reason for its importance.

    One of the key subjects that is always discussed when talking about the Battle of Crete is the impact it had on Operation Barbarossa. Some historians are keen to point out that Barbarossa was launched shortly after the Battle of Crete was won and make the suggestion that the invasion of Russia might not have gone ahead at all if Crete had not been captured. To discover whether this is indeed the case, we must examine several links between Operation Barbarossa and Operation Mercury: Hitler’s intentions towards both operations, the troop units that both operations shared, and the impact that the units used in the Battle of Crete made on the invasion of Russia.

    Hitler authorized the invasion of Crete in April 1941, making it clear that he wanted to use units that were already in the area as they were used during the invasion of Greece. He also stated that any units involved in the operation that had already been earmarked for Barbarossa should conclude their missions by the end of May so that they would be available for the invasion of Russia. In doing this, Hitler had made his position completely clear – Barbarossa was the priority and, if the invasion of Crete could not be launched in time, Operation Mercury would not go ahead at all.

    This would indicate that, in Hitler’s view at least, the inevitable capture or destruction of troops from a failed attempt to take Crete would have implications on Barbarossa. Hitler had made himself completely clear and by putting emphasis on his orders to have the units returned in time for Barbarossa, we can begin to suggest that a failed attempt on Crete may have had far greater implications for the German army than one might first think.

    The Deployment of Troops

    One of the things that the invasion of Crete did for the Germans was to help secure the Balkan flank. With Crete and, more importantly, its airfields in German hands, Hitler felt confident of launching the invasion of Russia without fearing a flanking attack through Greece. However, if the invasion had failed, and the units had been lost, this could have been quite a different story.

    The three main units that were involved in the German attack on Crete were the 7th Flieger Division, the 5th Mountain Division and the 8th Air Corps. The 7th Flieger Division were the main thrust of the attack and were dropped across Crete with the simple task to secure the airfields so that the 5th Mountain Division could follow. The 8th Air Corps operated from Greece, providing aerial support for the troops on the ground.

    In order to accurately determine how the loss of these units would have affected Barbarossa, we must address two scenarios. In the first, the 7th Flieger Division land on Crete but fail to take the airfields meaning that the 5th Mountain Division would never join the battle. In the second, the airfields are taken but an Allied counter-attack overruns them leaving both divisions to their fate. In the first scenario, the 7th Flieger Division would be all but destroyed meaning that it would not be available for Barbarossa, however the Mountain Division would have survived.

    But would this have made a vast difference to Barbarossa? In reality, whilst both units survived the battle, the number of German casualties was so high that neither unit took part in the opening stages of Barbarossa. The 7th Flieger Division would not return to full strength until September 1941 and the 5th Mountain Division would not end up on the Eastern Front until April the following year. In fact, out of the three main units, only the 8th Air Corps was ready to take part in Barbarossa and was swiftly returned to the Eastern Front to conduct pre-emptive strikes in June 1941.

    Even so, an Allied victory on Crete would have had a profound impact on the deployment of German troops in the region. If the Allies had held Crete, it is almost certainly true that Germany would have had to redeploy troops to protect the Greek coast against a possible Allied attack there. This would have meant rushing some of the units intended for Barbarossa down to Greece. In addition to this, the Allies would have still had three fully functioning airfields as the Germans would have left those intact to help supply their invasion. In order to combat the potential British attacks that may have followed, it is almost certain that the 8th Air Corps would have remained in Greece to conduct regular operations to knock out the British Air bases. It may have even been the case that, because of the threat from an Allied Crete, more aerial units would be moved down to Greece to help protect the convoys of supplies that travelled between Europe and Libya.
     
  2. lwd

    lwd Ace

    Joined:
    Jul 24, 2007
    Messages:
    11,730
    Likes Received:
    1,116
    Location:
    Michigan
    The title suggest an alternate history where Crete isn't invaded while most of the text looks at one where the invasion failed. I can see some potential for considerable differences.
     
  3. lordroel

    lordroel Member

    Joined:
    Nov 2, 2017
    Messages:
    40
    Likes Received:
    1
    Is it not the same, if Crete remains in Allied hands, the island is not under German control, but i could be wrong.
     
  4. lwd

    lwd Ace

    Joined:
    Jul 24, 2007
    Messages:
    11,730
    Likes Received:
    1,116
    Location:
    Michigan
    If no invasion is attempted the Germans don't end up with their airborne forces being badly shot up. The Italians don't loose several ships. The British also don't end up taking some fairly serious losses in both ships and men (navy and army).

    The Crete invasion also convinced Hitler not to sanction further combat drops without it they may have been utilized vs the Soviets.
     
  5. Carronade

    Carronade Ace

    Joined:
    Feb 17, 2010
    Messages:
    2,195
    Likes Received:
    337
    June 1942 is when the Halverson mission struck Ploesti with 13 B-24s. They met little opposition, presumably due to surprise, but this would not be the case for sustained operations. Crete is about 700 miles from Ploesti, so fighter escort would be out of the question until early 1944, and even then 8th Air Force might have priority.

    Historically Tidal Wave used bases around Benghazi and flew up the Adriatic and across Albania to avoid detection and interception for as long as possible, and still ended up with nearly 1/3 losses.
     
    Last edited: Oct 10, 2018
  6. Carronade

    Carronade Ace

    Joined:
    Feb 17, 2010
    Messages:
    2,195
    Likes Received:
    337
    The attack on Russia was Hitler's overwhelming priority; hardly anything could distract him from it. He went ahead despite having substantial forces tied down in the west and Mediterranean and about 1/3 of the Luftwaffe actively engaged against the British. Crete held or never attacked would be a small change in the overall balance.

    I'm not sure how much potential there would have been for using airborne troops in Barbarossa, given the speed of the ground advance, but the Ju-52s lost in Crete would have been a big help with logistics.
     
  7. lordroel

    lordroel Member

    Joined:
    Nov 2, 2017
    Messages:
    40
    Likes Received:
    1
    Could Crete be used as a base for attacks on the Romanian oil fields.
     
  8. lwd

    lwd Ace

    Joined:
    Jul 24, 2007
    Messages:
    11,730
    Likes Received:
    1,116
    Location:
    Michigan
    See Carronade's post #5
     
  9. lordroel

    lordroel Member

    Joined:
    Nov 2, 2017
    Messages:
    40
    Likes Received:
    1
    Sorry, thanks.
     
  10. Kai-Petri

    Kai-Petri Kenraali

    Joined:
    Jul 31, 2002
    Messages:
    21,929
    Likes Received:
    987
    Location:
    Kotka,Finland
    I cannot understand why Hitler spend so much blood on Crete and then used so many bombers and crews to make Malta almost bombed to kingdom come. And then did not even try to conquer it. Well you know my old idea. "Get Gibraltar" and shut down the faster route to the Mediterrenean area. Wrong or right but in the end the losses probably would have been pretty close the same as fighting the area 1940-1944. Perhaps even more as Hitler lost the some 300,000 men/tanks/guns in Tunisia alone as prisoners.
     

Share This Page