The above incoherent rambling is relevant how? Combining strawmen and your own lack of logic to another is neither correct, reasonable, or appreciated. Unfortunaly with you it's SOP. You got that rather backwards the reality is that it is related. Are you trying to illustrate that you don't understand English or logic or both. For a number of reasons not all completely understood flu cases become more common and severe during the winter months. I have repeatedly agreed that it can and does occur at any time of year but that doesn't mean there is not a relationship with winter or for that matter summer (although the relationships are inverse increasing in winter and decreasing in the summer). Actually that doesn't require "special" logic at all but it wasn't exactly my point either. Influenza show a distinct correlation with winter across both time and geography as has been documented on these pages. Furthermore it can be serious enough, indeed it is very often serious enough, to at least degrade the performance of soldiers if it doesn't require hospitalization much less kill them. The above effect if applied to German soldiers would constitute hurting the German army in any reasonable definition of the term. And this is relevant how? Or is it simply another attempt at diversion. When you are proven wrong you would be ahead to simply let the matter drop if you don't have the class to admit you are wrong. Digging yourself deeper into a hole does nothing for your reputation or your arguments.